In Avowed, the decision to attack or spare Captain Aelfyr during the mainline quest "A Path to the Garden" presents a significant choice that impacts your gameplay experience. If Captain Aelfyr was involved in the destruction of Fior Mes Inverno and reveled in the town's massacre, the temptation to seek revenge is strong, especially given Giata's anger. Moreover, your choice directly affects the loot you can acquire.
Should You Attack or Spare Captain Aelfyr in Avowed?
When faced with the choice, attacking Captain Aelfyr is the recommended action in Avowed. This decision unlocks access to unique loot, most notably the Death Knight Gloves, which you wouldn't obtain by sparing her.
Death Knight Gloves & Other Rewards for Attacking Aelfyr
- Garnet (Gem)
- Silver Fenning coins x26
- Exceptional Scale Armor (+0/3)
- Exceptional Great Sword (+0/3)
These items, especially the Exceptional Quality armor and weaponry, provide a great chance to enhance your gear if you've been neglecting upgrades. Additionally, you can loot the bodies of the dead Steel Garrote soldiers for further rewards.
What If You Spare Aelfyr?
Choosing to spare Aelfyr yields no tangible rewards. The primary benefit is avoiding a challenging fight against her and the Steel Garrote soldiers, which includes aggressive melee fighters and healing mages. On normal difficulty, this battle can be tough, so sparing her might be appealing if you're under-leveled. You can also adjust the game's difficulty to make the encounter more manageable.
Your decision will slightly affect Giata's mood—making her happier if you kill Aelfyr and more anxious if you spare her. However, these consequences are minor and don't significantly alter the storyline beyond a few discussions.
Given these considerations, attacking Captain Aelfyr in Avowed is the best choice for maximizing loot and gear upgrades. For further gameplay tips, explore whether you should give Keipo the Leviathan Heart during the "Heart of Valor" side quest, and review the complete list of Avowed's main and side missions to plan your next steps.
